Àkà nnà Olúwaségún
The Literary and Debating Society of the University of Ibadan (TLDS' UI) has responded to the withdrawal of Alexander Brown Hall (ABH) Literary and Debating Society from the ongoing Jaw War: *Rise of Legends* competition.
In a public statement issued on Friday, November 29, 2024, the society addressed concerns raised in an open letter by ABH constituencies, particularly from the Faculties of Clinical Sciences and Dentistry.
Acknowledging the emotional stakes in a competition as intense as Jaw War, TLDS' UI stated, “... _while we understand that such losses are painful, we must emphasize that the determination of the winners, the grading, and evaluation of speakers are the sole responsibility of the judges._” The society maintained that the selection of judges was conducted transparently, with input from senators of all constituencies.
In response to ABH's demand for the public disclosure of judges' score sheets, TLDS' UI raised concerns over the safety and integrity of the judging process. The society cited instances of verbal attacks on judges in the past, particularly from some constituencies now advocating for transparency.
“Revealing the score sheets could expose judges to unnecessary pressure and threats, thereby compromising the integrity of the competition,” the statement read. However, TLDS' UI expressed willingness to explore frameworks for improved transparency in future editions of the competition.
The TLDS also refuted allegations of errors attributed to the timekeeper during the debates, describing the claims as unsubstantiated. The society challenged ABH to provide evidence of any lapses, reiterating that the timekeeper adhered strictly to established guidelines.
Additionally, the statement criticized the informal approach taken by ABH in lodging complaints. “Grievances should follow due process, not be directed casually to executive members,” TLDS noted, describing this as a breach of professional conduct.
Despite the withdrawal of ABH, TLDS' UI expressed openness to dialogue and urged the constituency to reconsider its decision. The society warned, however, that the absence of ABH's constituencies—Clinical Sciences and Dentistry—would have consequences for their participation in future editions.
The statement concluded with a call for all constituencies to uphold the spirit of sportsmanship and engage positively in the competition. “We remain committed to fairness and the continued success of Jaw War, which serves as a platform to foster intellectual excellence and camaraderie.”
